180 Degrees Leaderboard08 - 180 Degrees Leaderboard08
Restaurant Review

Black Sheep: Quaint and Tasty

Carver's Black Sheep is more like a dark horse.

Black Sheep: Quaint and Tasty



Related Articles

More Restaurants & Dining »

Ginger Warder
Richmond.com
Friday, July 11, 2008

Located in the Carver District, on West Marshall directly behind the VCU complex on Broad Street, the Black Sheep may be close to the college and affordable, but everyone will love the homey food and arty atmosphere of this tiny eatery.

 

Starting with a great breakfast selection that's served until 2 p.m., the Sheep offers contemporary comfort food with a dose of nostalgic décor thrown in for good measure. Sausage Gravy & Biscuits sit comfortably next to Huevos Rancheros and a selection of Frittatas on the breakfast portion of the menu, but you can mix and match soups and salads with egg dishes to create your own perfect brunch.

 

I loved the Grillades & Grits, which were thin and very tender pork cutlets simmered in brown gravy with onions and tomatoes and served with wonderful cheese grits. For my "Breakfast Dessert," I couldn't resist the signature French Toast slathered with hazelnut spread, battered and grilled and topped with an orange syrup. Next time, I may try the Barn and Bay Breakfast Sandwich, a mix of scrambled eggs with crabmeat and ham on Texas toast.

 

Since I visited around 1 p.m., I tried some lunch items as well, including a rich white cheddar and asparagus soup and an absolutely huge meatball sub called the USS Monitor. This baby measured a full 18 inches and the crusty baguette was bursting with Swedish meatballs, green onions, Farmer's cheese, shredded cabbage and tomatoes. Three other sub choices include Mahi Mahi and pineapple, fried chicken livers with remoulade and grilled eggplant with white bean spread. Unbelievably, you also get your choice of one side item with this behemoth.

 

"Contemporary comfort food with a dose of nostalgic décor thrown in for good measure."

IF YOU GO:

The Black Sheep
901 W. Marshall St. 
(804) 648-1300

Hours:
Tuesday to Thursday: 9 a.m. to 9 p.m.

Friday to Saturday: 9 a.m. to 10 p.m.

Sunday: 9 a.m. to 8 p.m. 

Four smaller sandwiches include the Black Sheep's Southern-style club sandwich with pimento cheese, a spicy avocado, bacon and cheddar with horseradish, barbequed pulled turkey and a traditional roast beef on an onion roll. The three salad selections are all interesting: the Goat's Head with goat cheese, grapes, apples and celery, the Chico with spinach, endive, blue cheese, almonds and clementines, and the Spice Trade, frisée  tossed with Asian pear, avocado, scallions and a spiced yogurt dressing. 

All breakfast and lunch choice run from $4 to $8, and portions are generous in every category, including oversized mugs and cups of tea and coffee. If you're hankering for a childhood favorite like grape Nehi, you can get one here, and the Black Sheep also has a selection of beer and wine.

The dinner menu (served from 5 p.m. to close) is small but enticing with Beef Stroganoff, Chicken & Dumplings and Blue Ribbon Pork added to the soups, salads and sandwiches. Desserts include more nostalgic flavors from Haystacks and Banana Pudding to Peanut Butter Pie and Pineapple Upside Down Cake. 

 

The restaurant only seats about 30 and service was very friendly, however a tad on the slow side since items are made to order. Expect to spend an hour here for a meal, but the quality and quantity of the food at such reasonable prices makes the wait worthwhile.

 

Chef and co-owner, Kevin Roberts, has a two-decade history in Richmond restaurants and before opening the Black Sheep, was the Executive Chef at the Governor's Mansion for two years. Now everyone in town can eat like Virginia's First Family, with the added bonus of having a great weekday brunch spot.          


Printer Friendly Version  Email Article to a Friend  RSS Feeds


10 comments.
Reza June
7/30/2008 at 5:00:24 PM Flag
Flag Comment
Richmond.com Article Feedback - Leave your comment today!

The food snobs posting on this review are just that; snobs. My wife and I paid the 'Sheep' a visit last week and we weren't disappointed, small but great ambiance, food was fresh, and delicious as expected.

If you're expecting instant food made from frozen go to a fast-food joint, that's probably where you belong.


love sheep - Email this User
7/28/2008 at 3:26:16 PM Flag Flag Comment
Richmond.com Article Feedback - Leave your comment today!

i went to black sheep for dinner with my parents on saturday. WE LOVED IT. don't go unless you want to relax and enjoy a great dining experience. i had the fish taco (SOOO GOOD) and my mom had the blue ribbon pork (it melts in your mouth) betty crocker my rear.my stepdad had the roast beef sandwich and he loved every bit. sit back and enjoy the black sheep.their buscuits and gravy are divine, too.


reader2
7/20/2008 at 12:28:39 AM Flag
Flag Comment
Richmond.com Article Feedback - Leave your comment today!

All of these reviews (style, richmond.com and the RTD) seem to list the great-looking menu items and talk about how much food you get without actually talking about the food. My husband and I were fairly disappointed, and the servers clearly had never waited many tables, and maybe had never had company in their homes. They were negligent at best, and incompetent at worst. The wait was ridiculous, and our sandwiches were just average. The drinks are priced well, and so is the food, but really, if we want the best sandwich in town, 8 and 1/2 and Coppolas would win any day.


No more sheep
7/18/2008 at 2:58:21 PM Flag
Flag Comment
Richmond.com Article Feedback - Leave your comment today!

I LOVED The Black Sheep on the first 2 visits.
Counting Sheep may be an option at Black Sheep while waiting on the service. The restaurant was barely half full, so I just could not imagine the service with a larger crowd. Also, if you are meeting people at Black Sheep, the manager/waitress will not seat you until the entire party is present. I was with a party of 3 and waiting on the 4th person who outside parking the car, and the restaurant was only half full (2 other couples in the restaurant, hardly a business night). They would not seat us; they were actually kind of rude in vocal tone. I can’t image why a young business would turn down the opportunity for extra drinks or appetizers the group may order while waiting on the last person, or just out of common courtesy to let the quests be seated. We had to wait outside as there was no room inside to stand.

I eat out for dinner every single night and have been to just about every restaurant in Richmond city, I have not had to wait for the entire party to be seated except for at Momma Zu’s, which I could understand why since there is such a long wait to get into the restaurant.


NO more sheep for me
7/18/2008 at 2:51:37 PM Flag
Flag Comment
Richmond.com Article Feedback - Leave your comment today!

Counting Sheep may be an option at Black Sheep while waiting on the service. The restaurant was barely half full, so I just could not imagine the service with a larger crowd. Also, if you are meeting people at Black Sheep, the manager/waitress will not seat you until the entire party is present. I was with a party of 3 and waiting on the 4th person who outside parking the car, and the restaurant was only half full (2 other couples in the restaurant, hardly a business night). They would not seat us; they were actually kind of rude in vocal tone. I can’t image why a young business would turn down the opportunity for extra drinks or appetizers the group may order while waiting on the last person, or just out of common courtesy to let the quests be seated. We had to wait outside as there was no room inside to stand.

I eat out for dinner every single night and have been to just about every restaurant in Richmond city, I have not had to wait for the entire party to be seated except for at Momma Zu’s, which I could understand why since there is such a long wait to get into the restaurant.


To the Food Snob...
7/18/2008 at 10:00:04 AM Flag
Flag Comment
Richmond.com Article Feedback - Leave your comment today!

Did it not occur to you that (see comment below) this place was reviewed by three pubs in the same week? For god's sake, there are only a handful of seats. I'm sure your complaints wouldn't happen under ridiculously slammed circumstances. No restaurant can expect to be perfect while current media darlings. Go back in a few weeks.


Food Snob
7/17/2008 at 10:41:55 PM Flag
Flag Comment
Richmond.com Article Feedback - Leave your comment today!

I tried this restaurant tonight and they werent kidding about the slow service. Also, HUGE mistake not getting the sandwiches, which looked great- I ordered blue ribbon pork and it was exactly like the recipe in my vintage Betty Crocker cookbook- I could have made this dish at home and saved myself most of the 45 minute wait. My husband had the chicken dumplings and they were better- filled with sage, very creamy and piping hot. Unfortunately, we split the white russian brownie for dessert and it was raw in the middle and the alcohol in it was uncooked.

The ambience is definitely 60's, and the menu reflects that with the kitshy comfort food.


The Duke
7/13/2008 at 5:36:16 PM Flag
Flag Comment
Richmond.com Article Feedback - Leave your comment today!

This could easily be the most boring restaurant review I have read. Ginger, I know you can provide better details than this.


reader
7/11/2008 at 10:25:20 AM Flag
Flag Comment
Richmond.com Article Feedback - Leave your comment today!

Why did Style, the RTD and Richmond.com all review the same restaurant in a span of 3 days?


yawn
7/11/2008 at 9:38:05 AM Flag
Flag Comment
Richmond.com Article Feedback - Leave your comment today!

Is this a review or a listing of the menu items?



Name: *
E-Mail:
URL:
Comment: *
What is 2 + 2? *
To help protect against spam, please answer the above question

  

Disclaimer: Richmond.com reserves the right to edit and/or publish your contributions via e-mail, story comments, etc. Inappropriate comments will be subject to immediate removal without notice.

Carytown Sushi - Carytown Sushi Strip08

Passport to Wellness - Passport to Wellness ETW 2008